Skip to content

Cookies on Esotorium

With your permission we use Google Analytics cookies to count visits and see which pages lead to an order. We don't use advertising cookies. You can change your choice at any time under “Cookie settings” at the bottom of every page. Cookies and privacy

Get your report

Law of Attraction: History, Evidence and How to Use It

By Updated 6 min read

The law of attraction is the New Thought belief that positive or negative thoughts bring positive or negative experiences into your life. The phrase first appeared in print in 1855, was turned into a general principle by Prentice Mulford in the 1880s, and reached a mass audience with the film and book The Secret in 2006. There is no scientific evidence that thoughts attract events; research on goals does show that how you think about the future changes how much effort you put in.

That gap is the useful part. The tradition says "think it and it comes"; psychology says that picturing the outcome alone can make you less likely to reach it, while picturing the outcome and the obstacle together helps. Below is the history, what the studies found, what the idea does well and badly in love, money and motivation, and a weekly practice that keeps the intention-setting without the magical promise.

The idea is about 170 years old and grew out of New Thought

YearWho and whatWhat it added
Mid-1800sPhineas Quimby's mental healingThe root of New Thought: mind shapes the body
1855Andrew Jackson Davis, The Great Harmonia, vol. IVFirst printed use of "law of attraction", about the soul and the afterlife
1886 to 1887Prentice Mulford, "The Law of Success"First statement as a general rule for everyday life
Early 1900sWilliam Walker Atkinson, Thought Vibration or the Law of Attraction in the Thought WorldThe "vibration" vocabulary still used today
1937 and 1952Napoleon Hill, Think and Grow Rich; Norman Vincent Peale, The Power of Positive ThinkingBusiness and self-help bestsellers
2006Rhonda Byrne, The Secret (film, then book)Mass audience; "ask, believe, receive"
2020s"Manifestation" trends on social mediaShort techniques such as 369, scripting and the whisper method

The dates and titles are summarised in the law of attraction entry, which also notes that the idea has no demonstrable scientific basis and that critics object to its borrowing of physics words such as "vibration" and "frequency". The Secret alone has sold about 30 million copies, so the idea is common enough to be worth understanding on its own terms.

The core claim is "like attracts like", and that is where it breaks

New Thought writers described people and thoughts as made of a kind of energy, so that a feeling "vibrates" and draws matching events. Modern versions add that you must feel the wish as already fulfilled. Two things follow, and they are worth separating. The practical part (deciding what you want, keeping it in view, noticing chances) is ordinary goal psychology. The metaphysical part (the universe arranging events in answer to your mood) has never been shown and cannot easily be tested. Most readers keep the first and drop the second, which is also the approach of this page.

Picturing success alone can lower your effort

The best-known research here comes from the psychologist Gabriele Oettingen, who separates expectations (a judgement that success is likely, based on past experience) from positive fantasies (pleasant images of the outcome). In her studies, expectations predicted effort and success, while vivid positive fantasies often predicted less of both: the mind enjoys the outcome in advance and relaxes. What worked better was "mental contrasting", picturing the wish and then the main obstacle in your way, which she later combined with if-then plans into a method called WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan). Her claims have critics too, so treat them as a strong lead, not a final verdict.

For the law of attraction this is a useful correction. "Feel it as if it has already happened" is the step most likely to backfire; "feel it, then name what stands in the way" is the version with evidence behind it.

Manifesting money is where the idea does the most damage

Money is the most common topic in manifestation content and the one with the clearest risk. The law of attraction entry cites recent research finding that people who strongly believe in manifestation report more success, and also take more financial risks and are more exposed to bankruptcy. A belief that the right mood brings money can make a risky bet feel safe. Use any money intention for behaviour you control ("I put a fixed amount aside on payday"), never as a reason to skip a budget, a contract or professional advice.

In relationships, you can only work on your own side

Intentions about love work best when they describe what you will do: be more open, end a pattern, say something you have been avoiding. Intentions aimed at a specific person ("make them call me") are where manifestation turns into a wish for control, and they tend to keep you waiting. Our article on the whisper method covers the most popular person-focused technique and how to use it without crossing that line.

Our manifestation quiz, answered twice

Our free manifestation method quiz shows how the techniques differ. It has four questions with four answers each; every answer points to one method, the method with the most answers wins, and ties go to the method listed first in this order: The 369 Method, Scripting, The Whisper Method, Affirmations, Manifestation Journaling, Manifestation Basics.

The quiz matches a technique to how you like to work: routine, writing, speaking or private visualisation. It says nothing about whether the technique will bring the outcome, and neither does any other test.

A weekly intention practice that keeps the useful part

  1. Wish: write one wish for the next four weeks that depends mainly on you.
  2. Outcome: picture the best result for one minute, as vividly as you like.
  3. Obstacle: now picture the main thing inside you that could stop it (a habit, a fear, tiredness at 9 pm).
  4. Plan: write one if-then sentence: "If it is 9 pm and I want to skip it, then I do ten minutes anyway."
  5. Review: once a week, note what happened. Many people tie this to the moon, setting the wish at the new moon and reviewing at the full moon; see moon phases and rituals, or the seasonal calendar in witchcraft for beginners.

None of this needs a belief in a cosmic law. If you do hold that belief, the steps still work alongside it, and the review shows you plainly what changed and what did not.

Frequently asked questions

Is the law of attraction real?

There is no scientific evidence that thoughts attract events. It is a New Thought belief. Research does show that how you think about goals affects effort, which is the part worth keeping.

Who invented the law of attraction?

No single person. The phrase first appeared in 1855 in a book by Andrew Jackson Davis; Prentice Mulford stated it as a general principle in the 1880s, and The Secret made it famous in 2006.

What is the difference between the law of attraction and manifestation?

Manifestation is the modern name for the practices built on the law of attraction, such as scripting, affirmations, the 369 method and the whisper method.

Why is manifestation not working for me?

Picturing the outcome alone can lower effort. Studies on mental contrasting suggest adding the main obstacle and an if-then plan, and choosing goals that depend on your own actions.

Can the law of attraction bring money?

Not by itself. Research links strong manifestation beliefs with more financial risk-taking. Use money intentions for habits you control, and get qualified advice for financial decisions.